Today News
A+ A A-

Expert: Unitary tax favors high brand cigar producers

A London School of Economics-trained economist, quoting the latest technical manual (Chapter 2) of the World Health Organization (WHO) on Tobacco Tax Administration, said a unitary tax system favors producers of expensive brands, a segment dominated by multinational tobacco companies.
Dr. Ernesto R. Gonzales, post-graduate professor at UP-Manila, said: “That’s why the European Commission, recognizing the health objectives of cigarette excises, simultaneously impose two types of taxes on tobacco — a specific tax to set a minimum floor which is high enough to discourage smoking and an ad valorem tax for progressivity.”
Gonzales cautioned lawmakers and pro-health advocates that they might be overlooking the issue of upshifting to premium brands under a unitary tax regime due to negligible gaps in retail prices.
Under provisions of Republic Act 10351 or the sin tax reformed law, the Philippines is now under a unitary tax regime where cigarettes are taxed P30 per pack regardless of classification (non-premium and premium).
“In fact,” said Gonzales, “the WHO manual, in page 45, indicates ‘an upwards substitutability (upshifting) when the price gap between cheaper and more expensive brands narrows. The price increase, due to higher taxation, may alter consumers’ marginal willingness to pay for product “quality” subject to income.”
According to him, “the hypothesis that the market share of lower-priced cigarettes falls when specific excises increase, as the relative price between higher- and lower-priced cigarettes is reduced, is supported by empirical evidence.
Sobel and Garrett (1997) find that increases in specific taxes reduced the market share of generic (lower-priced) brands in the US significantly.”
The manual further states: “Theory shows that profits are relatively higher under specific taxation (e.g. Delipalla and Keen, 1992). Moreover, a tax increase may lead to an increase in profits. More than 100 percent over-shifting (i.e. prices rise by more than the tax increase itself) is a requisite for an increase in profits: as a higher tax increases consumer price and reduces demand, for profits to rise, the after-tax mark up must rise. It is not therefore surprising that tobacco multinationals prefer specific taxes.”
Philip Morris International’s (PMI) 2015 annual report (page 57) supports this upshifting trend: “The decline in our cigarette shipment volume reflected the lower total market combined with lower consumption of our low and super-low price brands, following price increases in late 2014 and early 2015, partly offset by higher market share, driven by adult smoker uptrading (upshifting) to Marlboro, combined with market share growth of Fortune, reflecting the narrowing of retail price gaps with brands at the bottom end of the market.”
Collated data in the same page of the report also showed that Marlboro sales in the Philippines increased by 2.7 percent that roughly translates into billions of pesos.
Gonzales supported former National Economic and Development Authority chief Romulo Neri’s statement that the Table 1 of Southeast Asia Tobacco Control Alliance Tobacco Tax Index 2015 report shows only Brunei and Singapore out of 10 Southeast Asian countries with a unitary excise tax.

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.Basic HTML code is allowed.


What is it to hide?

25-05-2017 Charlie V. Manalo

What is it to hide?

When it comes to hypocrisy, nothing and no one can beat...

US-Saudi arms mega deal looks to counter…

25-05-2017 AFP and Tribune Wires

US-Saudi arms mega deal looks to counter Iran

WASHINGTON — Washington has announced a bumper arms dea...

The most guilty

25-05-2017 Tribune Wires

The most guilty

By the time you’re reading this, perhaps Janet Lim-Napo...

Superb ideas, impressive resolves, decis…

25-05-2017 Archbishop Oscar V.Cruz

Superb ideas, impressive resolves, decisive actions

Admirable are the government officials who think of mar...

Gambia tackles sleazy image to diversify…

25-05-2017 AFP and Tribune Wires

Gambia tackles sleazy image to diversify tourism

SERREKUNDA, Gambia — For decades, The Gambia has built ...

Conservatives flex Trump-era might on US…

25-05-2017 AFP and Tribune Wires

Conservatives flex Trump-era might on US campuses

BOSTON, Massachusetts — US universities are often basti...






Life Style




Copyright 2000-2012 All rights reserved, The Daily Tribune Publishing Inc.